Yeah, I know. So many people say that same thing, “What is Existential Advice?” And. I will get to that in a bit, but first I want to tell you about how I began to start offering free advice.
In the summer of 2012 I was volunteering at the Lunik Cafe (check it out at Glendon College if you’re in Toronto). A group of friends and I were building a beautiful garden on the back patio. One of my friends was dealing with some issues. I don’t remember the exact details of our conversation, and it really doesn’t matter That’s not what this story is about. We talked and worked, had a few drinks and a few smokes, and after a few hours we were done. The herbs and vegetables had been transplanted, a beautiful gazebo had been built, and my friend had found resolve in her problem. She thanked me and told me that I had given her great advice.
Over the next couple weeks I realized that many of my friends and associates looked to me for ways that they could solve their problems. One friend with an essay, another with relationship woes, one with family problems, and the list goes on.
On a later day, Ashley, a close friend of mine, was visiting for dinner. We were hanging in the sun on the front yard and I began to tell her what I was starting to notice how many people ask me to help resolve their problems. “Have you ever thought about giving free advice?” I laughed at the idea,”What? With a sign walking down the street?” “Well, maybe in a park.” I thought the idea was crazy, and it is. But if there one thing that I have learned about myself it’s that I’m crazy. I told her I would consider it, think about it for a while.
Within the next few days I was at Lunik again. I was employed there as a Physical Spaces Coordinator, I was chatting with Greg and threw the idea about giving free advice in a park. “Do it man!” That’s usually the response I get from Greg. I was still reserved about the idea as Greg was sold on it and started giving me ideas for what to call it. “Advice with Peter”, “Free Advice with Peter”, and “Free Philosophical Advice”. I was still considering whether or not I was going to do it. “What about ‘Free Existential Advice’?” I said. And there it was, I had a name. Several days later I would be sitting in Kensington Market on a beautiful sunny day, with my pipe, in a sarong awaiting a new friend.
Being the resourceful and odd person that I am I decided to paint a thin wood board black, grab a few pieces of chalk, borrow some chairs from a local vendor where my friend Marijke works and began by sitting and waiting. I brought a book with me, I think I was reading Marx, to keep e occupied between clients… Clients? Not really. Customers? Well, I’m not asking for exchange. Let’s call them friends. My first friend was a young man who was dealing with a dilemma. One of the biggest questions that many people have. “How do I know what I’m doing with my life is what I should be doing?” How can I, someone who doesn’t know anything about this person, give him any substantial advice?
The hut I built at OM Fest
What is Existential Advice?
This is what I tell people. I categorize existentialism into two groups of problems/questions; questions of existence, and; questions within existence. The questions of existence are ones like, “Do I exist?”, “Does god exist?”, “Does the physical world exist?”, or “Do other people exist?” I don’t deal with those questions, because I can’t. I can only suppose and use my intuition in order to come to some logical answer. If you would like to think about these questions Rene Descartes in The Meditations on First Philosophy; And the Proof of the Existence of God.
The questions within existence is where the heart of people lives lie. it encompasses all of the problems that you face while you are living. Why are you having problems finding your soul mate? Why are you so happy when other people are sad? Why do you only have long relationships that end in your spouse cheating? Why do you have a hard time getting along with your boss? Why is your friend such an ass to you when he is around women? As you can imagine there are countless questions that could be posed. How would I be able to answer any of those questions without; not being a professional psychologist; not knowing the person I’m talking to, and; the limited amount of time that I have? I can’t, and I don’t.
Now you understand what an existential problem is, and you know that I cannot answer any of your problems… You’re probably asking, “Peter, what the hell do you do?” Well, I ask questions. One of the most important philosophical tools I learned in university was the Socratic Method. The ability to ask questions in order to find a solution is, what I believe, the only tool that a Philosopher, in the strict sense, uses. The term Philosophy has its roots in ancient times and is known to be coined by Pythagoras as a love/desire of wisdom. Socrates, in the Apology, uses this point very precisely. he makes sure to claim that he knows nothing and is in constant search for knowledge. The simple quote “I know that I know nothing” is a hefty paradox, but one that the philosopher would hold to. If I, being a philosopher, make a claim, am I still in search of knowledge?
This is what I do. I ask questions. Many people don’t understand how important it is to ask the right questions in order to find any fundamental truth about anything. All methods of inquiry about everything takes the same approach, but very few look to Socrates for gratitude. Why should they? Well, the only reason why we have discovered so many of the intricacies of existence is because we pondered, not because we asserted.
When you are facing a problem like “Why does my partner treat me without dignity or respect?” The answer that will lead you into a deep cycle of self-degradation is “I must be doing something wrong” or “It must be my fault” or “I must be a bad person, or else they wouldn’t treat me that way.” These may be right assertions, but do they help you at all? Will they help you find some resolve? No. I ask, “Why do you think they are treating you without dignity and respect?” Then maybe, “Are these actions really a sign of disrespect?” And, “What are the situations that you’re in when they treat you this way?” Or, “Why are you partners?” From this point there is a sleuth of questions and answers, until we find some sort of resolution. I will use anecdotes from other great philosophers such as Sartre, Plato, or Nietzsche in order to help the friend discover their resolution. That’s right! I will try my hardest to avoid giving anyone any advice. I don’t know these people, where they live, what their life was like, and what their passions are, so who am I to tell them how to live?
There are a couple things that help me in my dealings with people. I do my best to avoid judging people. If anything I let them judge themselves. I am sensitive to people who wish to keep secrets. Some people aren’t open to disclosing all of their private matters to some stranger in a kilt. I can understand that. Finally, my ability to use personal language. Using terms like “I feel” or “I think” are really important in dealing with personal matters. Using words like “maybe” are also really great for being inclusive.
My Experiences
Where do I do this? Everywhere. I do it with my close friends, in parks, on the transit, at music festivals, and while I’m hitchhiking. Some people have been brought to tears, others to extreme joy. Some leave with a heavy weight of questions to take home with them, ad others have a calm and relieved presence as they go on their way. I’ve had women, men, children, and the elderly approach me with questions and inquiries. I have dealt with people on drugs and people who are drunk. Each one of them has a soul, and if I can touch it, just for a moment, to leave them with something to consider, I’m joyously happy.
The greatest moment I had was when I was at Open Mind (an electronic music festival in Quebec). I was traveling through the labyrinth and ended up at this chill little spot with random people dressed in all types of funky clothes. “PETER!” I heard from the corner of the space. She was so happy to run into me. What felt even better what that she was so grateful of the advice that I gave her in Toronto about 3 weeks earlier. She was having a rough time in the relationship she was in. Her partner constantly made her feel like she was worthless, and she began to believe him. We spent about 3 hours in deep discussion. A lot of tears were shed and a lot of mental barriers were broken.
One thing that was hard to get over was the fact that I usually never see these people ever again. At the beginning I didn’t know whether or not I was helping people. I was worried that I was causing more harm than good. But after a while I discovered that what I was doing was helping, and most of all that people were enjoying it.
If you are ever dealing with someone and you think you might need a little help feel encouraged to speak with me. My belief is that I have to live in a world with all of you, I want to make sure you are doing well because if you’re having fun you are more likely to make fun for me.
Peace, Laugh, and Love…